Nike, the world’s top athletic apparel company is having a rough time – the brand once known for always innovating to stay fresh now appears stale and lacking in new ideas.
The company is changing its management in search of a better strategy for growth as its products are starting to fade out of contemporary trends and consumer preferences, writes eToro analyst for Romania, Bogdan Maioreanu.
New brands focusing on premium market segments, like Gap-owned Athteta or Lululemon, as well as its old rivals like Adidas and low-cost Chinese online sellers like Shein are eating away at Nike’s market share while investors are wondering what is next for the sportswear giant.
Nike reported financial figures for the first three months of the new fiscal year, which began on 1 June 2024, and the results were disappointing. The drop in revenue was already expected. However, what was not anticipated was the particularly poor performance of running shoe sales in the US (-14%) and Europe (-12%).
The large investments surrounding the Paris Olympics have not paid off as anticipated. In contrast, revenue in China, where many Western brands are struggling, only dropped by 2%. Nike faces stiff competition in the West including from European brands like On, Hoka, and Salomon, but also long-time rival Adidas, which quickly filled shelves in stores while Nike focused on direct sales.
At the global level Nike remains No.1 brand in Apparel, but the gap between competitors has narrowed according to the latest Kantar Brandz report. Zara’s 47% growth made it the second biggest riser in terms of rank change in the Global Top 100, rising 24 places to No.70. Lululemon’s innovative approach to athleisure and commitment to quality delivered 24% brand value growth, lifting it into the Global Top 100 for the first time in 92nd place. The overall apparel category gained 5%, driven by a strong performance from Zara, Shein, and Uniqlo while Nike’s brand value declined by 4% year-over-year, according to the report.
CEO John Donahoe had a rocky four-year tenure during which the company lost market share, strained relations with key retail partners and some said it lost its cool factor. In fact, the Back to School survey showed that consumer preferences are changing from Nike’s retro court styles to more colorful comfort shoes and “terrace styles”. It highlighted the increasing popularity of “dad shoes” like New Balance, Asics, and NIKE Vomero 5 and the strong adoption of styles like Adidas Samba, Gazelle, and Campus. Styles from Nike like Air Force 1, Jordan 1, and Blazer were losing popularity, the survey said.
This strategic error – the inability to shift from pandemic behavior to current trends in both style and purchasing habits – cost CEO John Donahoe his job and he will be replaced this month. The former consultant saw success with his direct-to-consumer (DTC) strategy during the pandemic when sportswear was massively ordered from home. However, in 2023, consumers returned to stores like Foot Locker, where they were excited about new brands and Nike failed to increase its presence there while its DTC did not perform as expected. Now, Nike is hoping that bringing the company veteran Elliott Hill out of retirement will reverse its fortunes. Hill started at Nike as an intern in 1988 and worked there his entire life until retiring in 2020. But competitors have the wind in their sails, and Nike has a lot to do to regain momentum.
The delay of the Investor Day, initially scheduled for 19 November, and the withdrawal of full-year revenue and profit forecasts indicate that a turnaround is not expected any time soon but was made to give new management time to assess what is to be done. Hill’s biggest challenge will be to reignite Nike’s innovation. Named after the Greek goddess of victory, Nike has a proven brand experience for athletes and regular users alike. Its greatest success, to this day, was the partnership with basketball legend Michael Jordan, who is now 61. In tennis, the firm entered the market with Ilie Năstase in the 1970s and had a long string of great champions up to Serena Williams and Rafael Nadal. Maybe it’s time for new icons to be brought to the forefront so that Nike can once again become invincible on the high street.
Nike’s share price, which has fallen by 50% over the past three years on the New York Stock Exchange, dropped another 6% after Tuesday night’s report. Investors are expecting to see how the new management will be able to steer the company toward growth in this highly competitive environment. During the last quarter, the company has seen a 9% increase in the number of Romanian investors owning its stock on the trading and investing social platform eToro. This might show that investors are buying the dip expecting a turnaround of Nike by the new management.
_
